The Re-Engagement Campaign
Wake up dead subscribers or cut them loose (stop paying for ghosts)
Overview
When to Use This
Objectives
- Re-activate cold subscribers with a pattern interrupt
- Get non-engaged people to unsubscribe (yes, this is good)
- Clean your list to improve deliverability rates
- Find out what content your audience actually wants
The Email Sequence
Did I lose you?
Preview: You haven't opened my emails in a while...
Timing
Send to anyone who hasn't opened in 60-90 days
Why This Email
Pattern interrupt. Most re-engagement emails are boring. This one isn't.
Email Template
Subject: Did I lose you? [First Name], You haven't opened one of my emails in [X] days. Which means one of three things: 1. My emails suck and you don't care 2. My emails are going to spam 3. You're busy and my stuff got buried If it's #1 → Just unsubscribe. No hard feelings. Link's at the bottom. If it's #2 → Move this email to your primary inbox and reply with literally anything. Even just "hi." It'll fix the spam issue. If it's #3 → Cool. You're still here. Here's what you've missed: → [Recent win/result/case study with numbers] → [Valuable piece of content you published] → [Upcoming thing they should know about] So what's it gonna be? If you're out, you're out. If you're in, reply to this and let me know what you actually want to learn about. I'll send it to you. [Your Name] P.S. If you're just not interested anymore, that's fine. But please unsubscribe instead of ghosting. It helps my emails reach people who actually want them.
MODULR Elements
Last call
Preview: This is the last email you'll get from me unless...
Timing
3-4 days after Email 1 (only to people who didn't open Email 1)
Why This Email
Final attempt with urgency. If they don't bite now, they never will.
Email Template
Subject: Last call [First Name], This is the last email you'll get from me. Unless you want to stay subscribed. I sent you an email a few days ago asking if you wanted to stay on this list. You didn't open it. So here's the deal: If you do nothing, I'm removing you in 7 days. If you want to stay, just click here → [Link to preference center or simple form] That's it. One click. Why am I doing this? Because I only want to email people who actually want to hear from me. Sending emails to people who don't read them is a waste of your time and mine. If you're out, no hard feelings. If you're in, click the link. [Your Name] P.S. If you're thinking "I'll just stay subscribed in case I want something later," don't. You can always re-subscribe. But right now you're making my emails go to spam for people who actually read them. So either click or we're done.
MODULR Elements
You're still here (welcome back)
Preview: Since you clicked to stay, here's what I need from you...
Timing
Immediately to people who clicked in Email 1 or 2
Why This Email
They re-engaged. Now find out what they want and deliver it.
Email Template
Subject: You're still here (welcome back) [First Name], You clicked to stay subscribed. Good choice. Now let me actually give you what you want. What do you want more of from me? A) [Topic 1 - specific area you cover] B) [Topic 2 - different specific area] C) [Topic 3 - another specific area] D) More of [your product/service] offers E) Something else (just tell me what) Hit reply and let me know: A, B, C, D, or E. I'm asking because you went cold for a reason. Maybe my content drifted from what you actually care about. Maybe you were too busy. Maybe I was sending too much. Whatever it is, I want to fix it. So tell me what you want, and I'll send you more of it. Fair? [Your Name] P.S. If you're ready to [achieve goal] instead of just reading about it, check out [your offer]. It's for people who are done learning and ready to do. → [Link]
MODULR Elements
Before & After Example
Before (Boring)
Subject: We miss you! Hi [First Name], We noticed you haven't opened our emails in a while and we wanted to reach out! We'd love to have you back as an engaged member of our community. Here's what you've been missing: • Our latest blog posts • Industry insights • Special updates We hope you'll continue to stay subscribed and look forward to connecting with you again soon! If you'd like to update your preferences, click here. Warm regards, The Team
After (MODULR)
Subject: Did I lose you? Sarah, You haven't opened one of my emails in 73 days. Which means one of three things: 1. My emails suck and you don't care 2. My emails are going to spam 3. You're busy and my stuff got buried If it's #1 → Just unsubscribe. No hard feelings. Link's at the bottom. If it's #2 → Move this to your primary inbox and reply with literally anything. Even just "hi." If it's #3 → Cool. Here's what you missed: → Case study: How a 3-email sequence generated $47K from 890 subscribers → The "boring email" framework that's killing your revenue → New MODULR Method workshop dropping next week So what's it gonna be? If you're out, you're out. If you're in, reply and tell me what you want to learn about. [Your Name] P.S. Please unsubscribe instead of ghosting. It helps my emails reach people who actually want them.
The Results
18.7% open rate (vs. 2-3% for typical win-back), 31% of openers replied, 12% clicked through to offers, 8% unsubscribed (which improved overall deliverability by 14%)
Customization Tips
- Segment by inactivity period: 60 days for B2C, 90 days for B2B
- Exclude anyone who's purchased recently - they're engaged even if they don't open every email
- The "just reply with hi" tactic in Email 1 actually works - it boosts your sender reputation
- Email 2's "I'm removing you" threat must be real - actually remove non-openers or you train them to ignore deadlines
- For Email 3, make the topic options align with your content calendar or product lines
- If you have product analytics, include people who log in but don't open emails - they're engaged differently
- Consider offering a frequency change option: some people want weekly instead of daily
- Add a final Email 4 for people who opened but didn't reply: "You opened but didn't answer - here's the best option based on what you originally signed up for"
What to Measure
- Open rate on Email 1 (aim for 15-25% - this is your "shock value" test)
- Reply rate on Email 1 (5-10% means your voice still resonates)
- Unsubscribe rate on Email 1 & 2 (don't fear this - it's cleaning your list)
- Click-through rate on Email 2 (8-12% is good for the preference center link)
- Response rate on Email 3 (anyone who answers is re-engaged - aim for 20%+)
- Re-activation rate (total people who open Email 3+ / total sent Email 1)
- Revenue from re-engaged segment in next 30 days (measure separately to prove ROI)
- Deliverability improvement (check your inbox rate before and after campaign)
Want Us to Implement This For You?
Stop copying and pasting templates. Get this playbook customized, written, and implemented in your business by the MODULR team.